Idol Girls

Here it is -- 3 nights of Idol this week! Girls perform tonight.

1) Paige goes first -- I wasn't that impressed. The judges like her voice...but I didn't care for it. But she won me over when she told the whole listening audience that she was 'sewn in' to her outfit and had been waiting for 5 hours to go pee! lol She deserves my vote for that!

2) Ashley R -- She is a beautiful girl. I think she chose a song a little too big for her. But I think she has a good voice. At this stage of the competition, the contestants should pic songs that are a bit more upbeat and fun...rather than the big Diva songs.

3) Janell W -- most of it sounded off-key to me. Not a very strong voice. And I didn't like the pants she wore...were they pants or tights with pockets?

4) Lilly Scott -- from living out of her car and performing on the street to being on American Idol...nice storyline -- and singing a Beatles song :-). She has her own unique style and that will get her quite far.

5) Katelyn -- Good voice, don't know what I think of the song choice? But a good performer.

6) Haeley -- Another Beatles song. It was shakey...but I liked her bringing her own style to it. She's young (16) and that will get her lots of votes. (Simon did hit upon what I was thinking the entire time -- she smiled the entire time -- almost too much!)

Half-way through the night...and Let me say I love Ellen as a judge! She tells it like she sees it and is the first to admit she may not know all the technical points of someone in the 'business' but she loves music and she knows what she likes!

7) Lacey -- a Texas Girl! She's got persistence (not her first time on Idol) and has a very unique look. Singing Fleetwood Mac song...Stevie Nicks is gonna be a hard one to be compared to. Very Good Voice. Not sure I liked the rendition, but I like her voice. The judges hated it. I do agree with Ellen -- she is better than that performance. We'll see. Come on Texas Voters...let's give her another chance!

8) Michelle -- So pretty! She looks like a model! Very confident and I think she did a great job!

9) DiDi -- Very unique! I love her vest! She has her own style and I like it (hope it doesn't grow old on me like some past contestants). She will have to shake it up some to keep it fresh.

10) Siobhan -- A glass blower? Interesting...She's got a different look tonight and she sang that song pretty well. -- though something tells me she is not the brightest crayon in the box!

11) Crystal -- I like her. And she picked a great song! Very talented! (I don't like the dreadlocks -- but I like her!)

12) Katie -- So cute! I have liked her since the first audition! Who wouldn't like the girl that loves her grandma so much! Great Song choice and awesome voice! She was the best performance/volcalist of the night! But my, my the judges are raking her over the coals. Yes, she needs to sing something more 'her age'.

So...2 of these will go home? I'm guessing it will be 3) Janell and 6) Haeley or 2) Ashley. What do you think?

Tomorrow night it's the guys!